For the anti-side, our strongest rebuttal was probably just that the standard conventions of punctuation would limit individual style(especially in the 21st century with Twitter, etc) and how punctuation is ever-evolving.
The other side makes a good point about how it is important for clarification, especially in academic or professional settings. Even though I was on the anti side, I find myself still debating whether the standards of punctuation is necessary. I understand how it's important in academic settings, but I find that most teens disregard punctuation on social networks or texting just because they assume people can understand them through the context.
An example of the "individual style" of punctuation is seen when teens choose to use a period or not. It's kind of funny that "Ok","Ok." are interpreted differently. A lot of people automatically assume that the period means, "Uh oh this person is pissed!" Also it is very, very rare to see correct punctuation on twitter. Most people just want the freedom of expression without having to worry about some "standard" that they have to follow. Punctuation not only puts in areas where there should be a pause-nowadays it also shows the tone, mood, and attitude.
Argument for punctuation:
A wonderful song regarding the oxford comma:
I completely agree with your assertion that punctuation nowadays shows tone, mood, and attitude. And I love your little song at the end!
ReplyDeleteI like your comic and video :) and I like your point that punctuation can change the way a reader interprets what's being said.
ReplyDeleteThe oxford comma reminds me of Mrs. Wright :) 8th grade memories awww
ReplyDeleteAnd yea your post was cool too